A Los Angeles judge has scheduled a May 3 trial in the long-running Steven Tyler sex assault trial, assigning the case to its fifth judge and signaling that earlier rulings may be revisited. Judge Lawrence Riff said at a Monday hearing in downtown Los Angeles that he would reconsider any orders issued by his predecessor, Judge Patricia Young, if either side requested it.
Young stepped aside in September, only two weeks before a previously scheduled trial date, after disclosing that she had discussed the matter with another judge who had already been disqualified from the case. Riff told the court he would review Young’s decisions from the start of her assignment based on arguments already on file, without accepting new briefing from either party.
Plaintiff Plans to Challenge Dismissal of Out-of-State Claims

Lawyers for the plaintiff, Julia Misley, said they intend to contest a ruling from earlier this year that removed a substantial portion of her case. That decision, a summary adjudication, dismissed Misley’s allegations involving conduct in Massachusetts, Oregon and Washington, leaving only claims tied to California.
Riff said both sides deserve confidence that the proceedings have been proper and free of any lingering doubt about possible impropriety. He acknowledged that the additional hearings would raise legal costs, but he said he expected the trial to remain in the first half of next year and did not believe the pretrial schedule would be unduly extended.
Defense Argues Earlier Ruling Should Stand
Before Riff’s announcement, Tyler’s lead lawyer, David Long-Daniels, argued that the court had no basis to revisit Young’s decision dismissing the claims from the three other states. He said the record showed no evidence that Young consulted the disqualified judge about that critical ruling, and that her contact with the other judge came later when she was weighing pretrial evidence issues.
Long-Daniels maintained that the summary adjudication was clear: California has no authority to try conduct that occurred in Massachusetts, Oregon or Washington. Misley’s lawyers countered that Young’s statements were ambiguous and that an extraordinary fact-finding process would be needed to resolve the question. Riff said court rules prevented him from speaking with Young unless both sides were present, and he declined to pursue that route.
The judge set a Nov. 20 deadline for either side to request review of any of Young’s orders. Any request to void one of those orders would be granted, he said, and he would then take up the matter himself. A new hearing on the key ruling that narrowed Misley’s case is expected in January.
Background of the Lawsuit
Misley filed the lawsuit in December 2022 under the California Child Victims Act, a 2019 law that temporarily revived otherwise expired claims by giving survivors of childhood sexual abuse a three-year window to sue. She alleges that Tyler sexually abused her for years beginning in 1973, when she was a high school sophomore and he was 25.
According to the lawsuit, Misley first met Tyler in Portland, Oregon, in 1973, a month after her 16th birthday. She claims they had sex that night and again in Seattle at the next stop on his concert tour. The age of consent in Oregon and Washington at the time was 18. Misley says she was groomed into a three-year relationship during which Tyler also brought her to California for an awards show and dragged her naked onto an elevator so he could have sex with her in a pool.
Tyler has denied the claims spanning three years and four states and asked the court to dismiss the entire lawsuit. He and his lawyers have argued that he lived with Misley in Boston for most of their relationship, where the age of consent was 16, and that Massachusetts law governed them even when they traveled to other states.
In his 2011 memoir, Does the Noise in My Head Bother You?, Tyler recalled the guardianship arrangement and their age difference, writing that he almost took a teen bride and that her parents signed papers giving him custody so he would not be arrested if he took her out of state. He also described having sex with Misley on a red-eye flight from Los Angeles to Boston and an incident at a Beverly Hills hotel involving a naked encounter in an elevator.
Misley has said that reading Tyler’s memoir led her to realizations about the trauma she experienced, giving her grounds to sue despite the statute of limitations. Tyler has countered that she knew about the alleged conduct all along and that the deadline to sue had expired.
