Retirement investors who stick with broad market index funds may be leaving money on the table, according to a new analysis from Dimensional Fund Advisors. The research suggests that a portfolio deliberately tilted toward size, value, and profitability premiums could provide a meaningfully larger nest egg by age 65—even if future market returns fall short of historical averages.
What the Premiums Are

DFA defines three long-term drivers of stock returns:
- Size premium: the historical tendency of small-cap stocks to outperform large-cap stocks.
- Value premium: the tendency of stocks with low price-to-book ratios to outperform the broader market.
- Profitability premium: the tendency of companies with relatively high operating profits to outperform less profitable firms.
To test the impact of emphasizing these traits, DFA compared the simulated performance of a standard broad-market index—represented by the CRSP 1-10 index—against its own Dimensional US Adjusted Market 1 Index. The DFA index holds 14% fewer stocks and gives greater weight to small-cap, value, and highly profitable companies.
Simulating a Lifetime of Saving

The analysis modeled a hypothetical investor who begins saving at 25 and retires at 65. Both portfolios follow a glide path that starts with 100% equities and gradually shifts toward bonds beginning at age 45, reaching a 50/50 stock-bond mix by retirement. DFA then applied the 4% withdrawal rule—a common guideline suggesting retirees can withdraw 4% of assets in the first year and adjust for inflation thereafter—to see how long the money would last over a 30-year retirement.
Using historical returns of 8.1% annually, the premium-focused portfolio ended up worth 22% more than the broad market portfolio at age 65. Under a more conservative 5% annual return assumption, the DFA portfolio still delivered 20% more in median assets.
Lower Risk of Running Out

The premium approach also reduced the odds of depleting savings during retirement. With historical returns, the DFA portfolio failed in just 2.5% of simulations over 30 years, compared with 4.7% for the market portfolio—nearly half the failure rate.
The gap widened under the lower-return scenario. When annual returns averaged 5%, the DFA portfolio ran out of money in 12.9% of simulations, while the broad market portfolio failed 19.9% of the time.
Mathieu Pellerin, the DFA researcher behind the paper, noted that a portfolio with controlled, moderate exposure to these premiums can balance higher expected returns against slightly higher volatility and tracking error. In his view, targeting these long-term drivers is likely to increase assets at the start of retirement.
What It Means for Savers
Index funds and target-date funds remain low-cost, broadly diversified options for retirement savers. But the research suggests that for those willing to accept some deviation from the market, a factor-tilted approach may offer a more lucrative path—one that could mean a larger cushion in retirement and a smaller chance of outliving your savings.
