Puka Nacua’s Injury Leaves a Fantasy Void: Trade and Waiver Options to Consider

Puka Nacua’s Injury Leaves a Fantasy Void: Trade and Waiver Options to Consider

The Puka Nacua injury has sent shockwaves through fantasy football, leaving managers scrambling for answers. Rams head coach Sean McVay announced that Nacua will miss a significant amount of time due to an MCL/PCL sprain and turf toe. For the Rams and fantasy teams alike, replacing his production is virtually impossible. Nacua has been a unicorn, averaging 13.3 targets, 10 catches, 102.1 receiving yards, and 24.8 PPR points per game. His absence creates a massive void that cannot be filled by anyone currently on the Rams’ depth chart.

Why the Rams' depth chart offers little hope

Article image

When Nacua missed five games in 2024, the Rams turned to Tutu Atwell, Demarcus Robinson, and Jordan Whittington. None averaged more than 11.4 PPR points per game, and the offense sputtered, going 2-3 while averaging just 18.8 points per game. The offense simply wasn’t the same without Nacua, and history is likely to repeat itself. Help isn’t coming soon either: Davante Adams is out until at least Week 12, and tight end Terrance Ferguson will miss another couple of weeks with a hamstring injury. Fantasy managers should look elsewhere for solutions.

Trade targets to soften the blow

The goal is to find a receiver who can average around six targets per week, ideally with a good quarterback on a pass-heavy team. Here are some trade candidates who could serve as reliable Band-Aids:

  • Carnell Tate, Titans: He should be healthy coming out of the bye and has seen at least six targets in four of his past five games. His schedule is favorable, and Cam Ward is showing slow progress. Tate shouldn’t cost much and is the most appealing trade target on this list.
  • Jalen Coker, Panthers: Coker has been quiet lately, but he plays a lot and serves as a short-area outlet for Bryce Young. His target volume has dipped in recent weeks, and his schedule is mostly great until Weeks 15-17. His low cost makes him very appealing.
  • Jordyn Tyson, Saints: The rookie had a sensational 31.3% target-per-route run rate in his debut, lining up in the slot as much as out wide. With the Saints lacking a reliable run game and facing a manageable schedule, Tyson should see plenty of targets and could emerge as the team’s second option.
  • Denzel Boston, Browns: Boston has seen at least seven targets in five of his past six games and has nine red-zone targets on the year. However, his quarterback play limits his ceiling, as evidenced by his 83.6% catchable target rate. The Browns’ run game is a mess, but their schedule after Week 11 is very favorable.
  • KC Concepcion, Browns: Concepcion also gets plenty of targets, but they’re mostly short-area screens and slants. His catchable target rate is slightly better at 85.5%, but his floor is lower. If the Browns’ schedule boosts the pass game after Week 11, Concepcion could break big plays after the catch.
  • Nico Collins and Garrett Wilson: These two are also good trade targets, but their managers might demand a hefty return. If you’re willing to pay up, they’re worth pursuing before the cheaper options.

Waiver wire options to consider

If trades aren’t your thing, several receivers are available on waivers who could provide immediate help:

  • Tank Dell, Texans (22% rostered): Dell saw nine targets despite a 55% route rate in a blowout win over the Chargers. Seven of those were deep shots, and C.J. Stroud clearly loves having him back. With the Texans’ run game struggling, their playoff push will rely on Stroud’s arm.
  • Makai Lemon, Eagles (59% rostered): You’ll have to navigate his Week 10 bye, but the Eagles’ depleted defense suggests they’ll throw a lot. Even with DeVonta Smith returning, Lemon should remain in the six-target range.
  • Caleb Douglas, Dolphins (73% rostered on CBS; lower elsewhere): Douglas appears to be Miami’s No. 1 receiver moving forward. He has good size and speed, and the Dolphins’ offense should lean pass-heavy. Despite some tough matchups, he’s worth a look.
  • Adonai Mitchell, Jets (63% rostered): His zero-catch game against the Chiefs might scare you off, but Geno Smith keeps targeting him. A week earlier, he had 142 yards and a touchdown. His schedule gets tougher near the fantasy playoffs, though.
  • Tutu Atwell, Rams (1% rostered): Atwell stepped up in 2024 when Nacua was out, and he’s a known quantity to the coaching staff. He’s unlikely to replicate that success, but he’s worth a flier in deep leagues.

Streaming options if you're desperate

If you don’t mind streaming, consider Ryan Flournoy (59% rostered), Demario Douglas (82% rostered on CBS; lower elsewhere), Jordan Watkins (25% rostered), Mack Hollins (12% rostered), and Xavier Hutchinson (6% rostered). Hutchinson, like Dell, should see plenty of slot work in the Texans’ pass-heavy offense.

The Puka Nacua injury is a brutal blow, but fantasy managers can still find viable replacements by exploring trades and waivers. The key is to act quickly and target receivers who offer consistent volume and favorable schedules.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *