At the Love Is Blind season 11 reunion, Matt Waldrip confirmed that he and Michaella Giorgio did pursue a romance after the pods—a claim Michaella Giorgio and Matt Waldrip dated was not entirely accurate in her view. The revelation came during the Nov. 8 special when host Nick Lachey asked the beekeeper whether he had ever harbored feelings for Michaella. Matt answered by saying the two had a relationship after the experiment ended, and that he felt fortunate she welcomed him into her life and introduced him to her family.
A Confession and a Correction

Matt described the experience as meaningful, telling Michaella he had fallen in love with her during that period and apologizing for being the one to end things. He wished her happiness and said she would always hold a special place in his heart. Michaella, however, cut him off before he could finish, repeating that she needed nothing from him.
When she gave her own account, Michaella characterized their time together as a friendship that should never have become romantic. She said they dated for a few weeks, and that she met his mother when she dropped him off at his mom’s house. She also pushed back on the idea that they were in love. Matt maintained that his feelings were genuine, noting that Michaella had joined him and his family at a production of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child and that her mother makes memorable chicken cutlets.
Michaella then offered a clarification: she had told Matt she loved him, but not that she was in love with him—and she noted she was on mushrooms at the time, which she said he knew. Matt responded that her version of events was a shame and remarked that he was glad he had not brought the homemade honey he had considered giving her.
Closing the Chapter With Rob Feeley
The reunion also gave Michaella and Rob Feeley a chance to address their broken engagement. Michaella said she had no regrets and that she had truly fallen in love with him, adding that she would always love him and that it was a shame how things ended. Rob, for his part, said everything he had said to her was genuine from the day they met through the present, and he apologized for letting her down. He told her she deserves better and offered to remain a friend she could reach out to.
The pair’s relationship had unraveled during the season after Rob’s public outbursts, including an incident at a bar and a confrontation at a cast meet-up. Michaella later said through tears that she could not marry him under any circumstances.
Where the Rest of the Cast Stands
The reunion also confirmed the status of several other season 11 couples, none of whom remain married:
- Blake Carver and Erika Ellis called off their wedding a week before the ceremony, citing conflicting lifestyles tied to Blake’s long stretches at sea.
- Wilson Monteiro and Wilnie Louis split over disagreements about sharing household responsibilities.
- Cam Halloran and Aneha Singh parted ways after Aneha said she needed more time at the altar; they confirmed at the reunion that the relationship ended for good.
- John Shannon and Sarah Williams are divorcing. John admitted at the reunion to exchanging inappropriate messages with a stripper and escort he met on a night out, and Sarah filed for divorce shortly before the special aired.
- Scott Stewart and Jacqueline Guelli ended their engagement but remain friendly and live near each other in Boston.
For Matt and Michaella, the reunion made clear that whatever existed between them after the pods is now firmly in the past—with two very different memories of how serious it was.
