A Gas-Rich Ghost: The Galaxy That May Have No Stars

Image may contain Nature Night Outdoors Performer Person Solo Performance Adult and Photography

Astronomers have found a compelling candidate for a massive starless galaxy: an object labeled AGC 322753 that appears to hold about 2 billion times the sun’s mass in hydrogen while showing no detectable starlight. The result, published in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, raises fresh questions about why some galaxies ignite stars and others remain dark.

The research was carried out at Swinburne University of Technology in Australia. The team combined observations from two radio surveys: one from the Arecibo Observatory in Puerto Rico and another from China’s Five-Hundred-Meter Aperture Spherical Radio Telescope. Both instruments had recorded a large cloud of hydrogen at the same location.

Why dark galaxies matter

Image may contain Nature Night Outdoors Performer Person Solo Performance Adult and Photography

Dark galaxies—objects with gas and dark matter but little or no star formation—are expected in the standard cosmological model, known as Lambda-CDM. That framework assumes dark energy and cold dark matter, with the latter thought to make up roughly 85 percent of the universe’s matter. Dark matter haloes provide the gravitational framework in which gas gathers, cools and eventually collapses into stars. Yet the process does not occur in every halo, and astronomers have struggled to explain the difference.

One proposal is that some haloes contain enormous amounts of hydrogen but produce almost no stars, making them extremely faint and hard to detect. AGC 322753 fits that description, though the authors caution that it is probably too massive to be entirely starless. If confirmed, it would be an unusually large example of a dark galaxy.

A hint of rotation

What makes AGC 322753 stand out from earlier dark galaxy candidates is a possible sign of rotation. Hydrogen emits radio waves at a characteristic wavelength; the signal shifts shorter as gas approaches Earth and longer as it recedes. The signal from this object shows two distinct peaks, which could mean one side of the cloud is moving toward us while the other moves away.

That pattern would suggest the gas has settled into an organized, rotating structure resembling the discs of ordinary galaxies—even though no stars have been seen. Marco Monaci, a study author at Swinburne, noted that theoretical models and simulations generally do not predict rotation in dark galaxies, making the finding especially intriguing. If AGC 322753 is indeed a rotating starless disc, astronomers would need to explain how its gas became organized without forming stars.

The missing starlight puzzle

There is a second problem. Most galaxy formation models predict that a cloud with this much hydrogen should have produced at least a few stars, since its densest regions should collapse under gravity and ignite. The coauthors therefore consider it unlikely that AGC 322753 contains absolutely no stars. Instead, they suggest it may host stars too faint to detect—an “almost dark” galaxy.

Deep optical images from the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys, which look for starlight rather than radio-emitting gas, revealed none. From that absence, the team estimates the object holds at least 40 times more mass in hydrogen than in stars.

Caution and follow-up

Confirmation will require further observations, such as those from the Very Large Array, a network of radio antennas in New Mexico. Robert Minchin of the National Radio Astronomy Observatory said more study is essential and that the object is intriguing. Minchin knows how misleading such signals can be: he was involved in the discovery of VIRGOHI21, an early dark galaxy candidate later reinterpreted as a tidal tail—a stream of hydrogen pulled from a nearby galaxy by gravity. Gas torn away in that way can retain some of its original motion and mimic rotation, so Minchin says follow-up work is needed to rule out the same explanation. There is, however, no obvious nearby galaxy that could have supplied such debris.

Rhys Taylor of the Astronomical Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences in Prague said tidal debris is unlikely to account for the observations. Reproducing the double-peaked signal through such a process is technically possible but highly improbable, he said.

Taylor and Minchin also point to another concern: the two radio surveys placed the hydrogen at noticeably different positions on the sky. That could mean AGC 322753 is an extended cloud rather than a compact galaxy, a possibility that follow-up observations could resolve.

What almost-dark galaxies can teach

Whether AGC 322753 turns out to be completely dark or merely exceptionally faint, studying such objects could help explain why some galaxies form stars and others do not, according to Elisabeth Adams of the Planetary Science Institute. One possibility is that a galaxy spins so rapidly that its gas remains too spread out to collapse. Another is that ultraviolet light from the universe’s earliest stars heated the gas, keeping it too warm to condense. Almost-dark galaxies could help distinguish between these scenarios and reveal how early cosmic conditions shaped the galaxies seen today.

Adams also argued that interest should not fade once an object stops being classified as a dark galaxy. If AGC 322753 is truly starless, it would be one of the most massive dark galaxies ever identified. That could help explain where the missing galaxies predicted by Lambda-CDM have been hiding, and it could offer a valuable test of galaxy formation models—perhaps even new clues about dark matter itself.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *