CJ Carr Seizes Heisman Lead, but Notre Dame’s Schedule Poses a Risk

CJ Carr Seizes Heisman Lead, but Notre Dame’s Schedule Poses a Risk

The CJ Carr Heisman odds underwent a major shift after Notre Dame’s statement win over Miami, but the quarterback’s path to the trophy may be complicated by the Fighting Irish’s remaining schedule. Carr, a junior, entered the weekend as a +500 third choice and exited as the +190 favorite, according to DraftKings.

Why Carr's Stock Surged

Article image

Carr delivered a near-flawless performance in Notre Dame’s 31-24 upset of the then-No. 1 Hurricanes, completing 29 of 40 passes for 319 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions. The source notes he became only the fifth FBS quarterback in the past 30 years to post at least 300 passing yards and three scores without a pick against the nation’s top-ranked team. The others were Ohio State’s Will Howard, Alabama’s Bryce Young, Clemson’s Trevor Lawrence and Clemson’s Deshaun Watson.

The victory also lifted Notre Dame’s College Football Playoff prospects. The Irish are now -4000 to reach the playoff, second only to Georgia at -9000. Notre Dame can secure its spot by winning its remaining regular-season games against Boston College, SMU and Syracuse, though the source cautions that those matchups are not guaranteed victories.

The Schedule Factor

Notre Dame’s independence cuts both ways. The Irish will not play a conference championship game, which guarantees them rest and a likely playoff berth if they remain in the final top 12. However, the absence of a title-game stage could deprive Carr of a final showcase before Heisman votes are due on Dec. 7, the Monday after conference championship Saturday.

The source suggests that Carr’s biggest threat may be the lack of a signature late-season opportunity compared to rivals who will compete in conference title games. Still, if Notre Dame wins out, Carr’s candidacy appears strong. The program has not produced a Heisman winner since Tim Brown in 1987, and its last quarterback to win was John Huarte in 1964. Brady Quinn was the last Irish quarterback to finish in the top three, in 2006.

Chasing Pack

Miami’s Darian Mensah, the +170 second choice entering the weekend, remains No. 2 but drifted to +250 after a season-worst 55.8% completion rate and a season-high 19 incompletions in the loss. The Hurricanes were without star receiver Malachi Toney, and the source notes that Mensah will not have to split Heisman votes with a teammate for the rest of the regular season and ACC title game. However, Miami’s remaining schedule lacks a marquee opponent, making it difficult for Mensah to overtake Carr unless the Notre Dame quarterback falters.

Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, the +150 favorite before Saturday, fell to +280 after the Buckeyes’ 41-28 home loss to Oregon. The source indicates that Ohio State is essentially out of the playoff with three losses, and the injury to quarterback Julian Sayin in the Oct. 17 win at Indiana damaged the season and Smith’s Heisman chances. Smith caught seven passes for 133 yards and a touchdown against the Ducks, but the source argues that a playoff contender is now a prerequisite for Heisman contention.

Utah quarterback Devon Dampier made the biggest move among long shots, jumping from +10000 to +1500 after leading the Utes to a 28-20 win over BYU. Dampier threw for 177 yards and two scores and rushed for 87 yards and two touchdowns in Utah’s 15th consecutive victory. It was his 17th straight game with at least two touchdowns. The source notes that Dampier’s candidacy could be short-lived because the Utes face a potential letdown game at No. 22 Arizona this Saturday, then close at TCU and at home against West Virginia before a likely Big 12 title game. That conference championship platform could give Dampier a national window that Carr will not have.

Georgia’s Gunner Stockton, quarterback of the new No. 1 team, sits at +2700. The source doubts he can produce enough statistically to catch Carr, Mensah or Dampier.

Bottom Line

Carr’s Heisman case is built on a marquee win and efficient production, but the source identifies Notre Dame’s schedule as the main risk. With no conference championship game to pad his resume, Carr may need to maintain his current form and hope that voters weigh his Miami performance heavily. The source concludes that Carr is the pick today and suggests this could be the last week he is available at plus-money odds.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *