Michael Carrick’s future at Manchester United is still unresolved, with the club’s board yet to reach a final verdict on the head coach’s position.
Mixed Results Leave Board Weighing Options

The 4-4 draw with Aston Villa on Sunday extended a difficult sequence that has left United 18th in the table and marks the club’s worst start to a domestic season in four decades. That match was Carrick’s third in charge since the board opted to give the 45-year-old additional time to lift the side’s form following a 3-0 home loss to Bournemouth on 25 October. The decision to wait was influenced by a belief that Carrick and the players deserved a chance to demonstrate improvement, as well as an awareness that the two-week November international break would allow for a calmer review.
That review is now under way, and the evidence from the past three fixtures presents a divided . A single win, one draw and one defeat, eight goals conceded and a slide into the relegation zone are clear concerns. Yet the team’s repeated comebacks from two-goal deficits in the last two matches have been interpreted as a sign that the players remain committed to Carrick.
Managerial Alternatives Explored

After the Bournemouth defeat, United’s hierarchy examined possible replacements for Carrick, with former Newcastle boss Eddie Howe and ex-Germany head coach Julian Nagelsmann among those considered. Carrick stated after the Villa draw that he would not step down, but chief executive Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox are expected to play a significant role in determining whether he continues. United’s next fixture is a trip to arch-rivals Liverpool on 22 November, their first match after the international break, with the side sitting 18th in the Premier League.
With only one league victory this season, United are in their lowest position after 10 matches since the 1986-87 campaign. After the Anfield visit, five of their next seven league opponents are in the bottom half of the table, including the four other sides currently in the bottom five, with home meetings against Coventry, Nottingham Forest and Sunderland.
Defensive Frailties Persist

Regardless of who is in charge, United’s difficulties are likely to continue unless they stem the flow of goals conceded. Only Crystal Palace and Ipswich have let in more than United’s 19 league goals, and the team has shipped 15 in its past three matches across all competitions. Their sole clean sheet this term came against Azerbaijan champions Sabah FK in the Champions League.
Former United assistant boss Rene Meulensteen told BBC Radio Five Live that opposing Premier League teams now approach matches against United with confidence, believing they can create and score chances. He added that Carrick will be constantly uncertain about his best back four because there is no guarantee of a clean sheet.
Full-back Diogo Dalot faced the brunt of supporter frustration at Old Trafford on Sunday. Cheers greeted the announcement of his substitution, turning to boos as he reached the dugout. Substitute Joshua Zirkzee, who received similar treatment when withdrawn after half an hour of a home defeat to Newcastle in December 2024, made a point of embracing Dalot as he returned to the bench. Asked whether Dalot should be taken out of the firing line, Carrick urged caution.
Carrick said he understands the supporters’ frustration and disappointment, adding that the players share those feelings. He praised Dalot’s commitment and versatility, acknowledging that the defender gave away a penalty and could have done better on the play, but stressed that Dalot cares deeply and gives everything for the team.

