The American Film Market opens today in Los Angeles, and the AFM horror market is already showing signs of strain. Buyers arriving at the annual gathering describe an overwhelming volume of affordable genre projects, with one comparing the influx to an avalanche. The mood is not entirely enthusiastic: a buyer admitted that the constant stream of horror pitches has become exhausting, particularly when every other project is described as being in the vein of Obsession.
That frustration, however, comes with an important caveat. The fact that films like Obsession, Backrooms and Buddy exist at all has helped drive a resurgent theatrical box office this year. None of those titles were traditional market packages, but independent distributors in various territories had opportunities to acquire them. Two of the three launched at festivals, while Backrooms was offered to buyers through A24, which had set up the project. In each case, a studio eventually became involved in some form — a component that remains crucial for many breakout successes.
Genre Saturation Meets Star Power

While the horror glut dominates conversation, the market floor also features a mix of star-driven projects and high-profile adaptations. A24’s Elden Ring is among the titles hitting the market, alongside new films featuring Jeremy Renner, Idris Elba, Gillian Anderson and Renée Zellweger. The presence of such names suggests that even in a crowded genre space, buyers are still searching for packages with recognizable talent and established intellectual property.
The challenge for sellers is standing out. With so many projects touting similar horror hooks, distinguishing a genuine commercial prospect from a copycat has become harder. The buyer who complained about the Obsession comparisons was not dismissing the film’s success but rather the market’s tendency to chase trends rather than cultivate original ideas.
What Buyers Are Watching
Despite the fatigue, the appetite for affordable genre content remains strong. The theatrical recovery has been fueled in part by titles that found audiences through a combination of festival buzz, independent distribution and eventual studio backing. That model has encouraged sellers to bring more projects to AFM, hoping to replicate the trajectory of recent hits.
For now, the market is a test of endurance and taste. Buyers must sift through a flood of horror pitches while keeping an eye on star-led packages that could offer safer returns. The next Obsession may be somewhere in the mix — but finding it will require patience.
