King Arthur’s Sourdough Sidekick Automates Starter Care, With Caveats

Image may contain Cup Computer Hardware Electronics Hardware Monitor Screen Beverage Milk Bottle and Shaker

This King Arthur Sourdough Sidekick review comes after three weeks of testing a countertop appliance designed to take the guesswork out of sourdough starter maintenance. The $180 device, a collaboration between King Arthur Baking Company and FirstBuild, GE Appliances’ product development lab, automatically feeds and stirs a starter so it is ready when you want to bake. For a full-time working parent who had not baked a proper sourdough loaf in over a year, it proved to be the push needed to get back into the routine.

What the Sidekick Does

Image may contain Cup Computer Hardware Electronics Hardware Monitor Screen Beverage Milk Bottle and Shaker

The appliance is roughly the size of a Mr. Coffee machine. It combines a built-in water reservoir, a flour hopper, and a glass crock topped with a stirring-paddle lid. A Quick Start Guide walks users through filling the reservoir and hopper, setting the current day and time, choosing a target day and time for the starter to be ready (up to seven days ahead), adding a small amount of existing starter, and pressing Auto Mode.

There is also a companion app through GE’s generic SmartHQ platform, but it is not required for basic operation. The app mainly displays current settings and sends a push notification when the starter is finished; it cannot adjust settings or control the machine. A firmware update did add power-loss recovery for up to 12 hours, which worked successfully when a tripped breaker cut power.

Calibration and Early Troubles

Image may contain King Arthur Sourdough Sidekick

The first attempt revealed a significant quirk: during the initial mixing cycle, flour released from the hopper but no water was dispensed, leaving an under-hydrated ball that grew drier over several days. The reservoir remained at its maximum fill line. After downloading the app and installing a firmware update, water began dispensing during mixing. The real fix, however, was following the main instruction booklet’s calibration process, which uses a scale to verify the amounts of water and flour the machine dispenses. That process is lengthy and fiddly, though it should only need to be done once—unless you switch between flour types, such as whole wheat or full rye, in which case recalibration is required.

A second attempt with saved seed starter went much better. The machine properly dispensed 30 grams each of water and flour daily and ran a stirring cycle every two hours. That cycle starts with a loud beep and a mechanical whir that can be startling, especially in the same room. The stirring can be disabled, but it serves to knock down the starter’s volume and reincorporate unconsumed flour, and the updated paddle did a good job of mixing each time.

Modes and Daily Use

King Arthur Baking the Sourdough Sidekick

Beyond Auto Mode, there is a Ratio Mode for setting starter-flour-water ratios such as 1:1:1 or 1:1:2, and a Custom Mode for specifying exact flour and water quantities and feeding timing, once or even twice a day. Custom Mode was the most-used option for switching between flour types for different breads. In a typical week, the crock was about two-thirds full by the end, holding more than 400 grams of starter—enough for two boules and a sandwich loaf, with seed left over for the next batch.

Because of the regular mixing and the lack of discard in Auto Mode (which prompts a discard after a week, while Ratio and Custom modes have discard reminders), the finished starter may not look as puffy or bubbly as a traditionally maintained one. The article suggests going by scent—tangy and clearly fermented—and trusting the process. Some online users recommend adding a few teaspoons of rye flour to all-purpose flour to boost growth, but no noticeable difference in appearance, smell, or performance was observed.

Temperature and Bread Results

Sourdough Sidekick Starter

The display shows ambient temperature, but unlike other starter gadgets such as the Goldie or Brod & Taylor’s Sourdough Home, the Sidekick cannot adjust the starter’s temperature. That could matter in a cold kitchen. It does offer temperature-aware feedings in Auto Mode, adjusting amounts based on detected room temperature.

Bread made with the Sidekick-maintained starter turned out no differently than bread made with traditionally maintained starter. If baking is not possible when the starter is ready, most of it can be discarded, leaving seed for the next batch, or the crock can be kept in the refrigerator for a few days with its metal lid before reviving the starter the traditional way. All removable components are top-rack dishwasher safe.

Who It Is For

Image may contain Bread and Food

At $180, the Sourdough Sidekick costs about $175 more than a spoon and a Mason jar. It is not a necessary device. But for someone who bakes often, or who is interested in sourdough but intimidated by starter maintenance, it is one of the more compelling kitchen-tech gifts available. The included directions also explain how to make a starter from scratch in the machine. For this tester, it ended a yearlong sourdough slump—perhaps permanently.

Image may contain Sourdough Sidekick app

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *